At Yahoo: Market Interventions

I write at Yahoo on Market Interventions:

(Posted in entirety)

There were riots in Bangladesh on Monday when markets went down 9% in an hour. Stocks fell, presumably because their central bank decided to tighten down on bank exposure to equity, and the general index has been slowly sliding from December. It may sound unreasonable to have such an event create a loss of 9% in a single day — or indeed the 27% loss in a month that Dhaka saw — but it comes on the back of a 2010 that saw the index rise 95 percent. Now that fall doesn't seem quite as bad, does it?

Shaken by the public furore, Bangladesh's central bank instructed banks to please buy stocks — and as expected, their index rebounded by 15% on Tuesday. The idea is to never mess with a good thing, I guess.

Intervention doesn't always work. In 2008, Pakistan's stock markets fell about 43% and to somehow stop that, the authorities decided to set a floor price on the index; meaning, stocks couldn't go below a certain value. What happened then, was that the floor became a ceiling — stocks would simply not trade above that level. When the floor was removed in December 2008, stocks fell another 35% before they rebounded.

Regulators impact markets in different ways. During the great fall of 2008 in the US, financial company CEOs pressed the authorities to ban "short-selling" — or, the ability to borrow and sell stocks, in the hope of buying them back later at a lower price. The ban, though in effect for a while, did nothing to salvage hopes of financial companies that were in deep distress — indeed, shares of Citigroup are still less half the levels they were before the ban.

In the early 90s, the Bank of England tried to keep the British Pound at a certain floor exchange rate to the German Deutsche Mark, but the fundamentals dictated otherwise: The UK was seeing high inflation but interest rates weren't as high compared to Germany, although at 10% one might think it was quite high — Germany was at 9.5%, and seeing an economic boom. This combination can't work for long — the British Pound would have to fall; but for a while the BoE thought they could support it. Eventually they gave up, and BoE opted out of the fixed exchange rate mechanism, in the process making George Soros famous (and rich!) for betting against the Pound.

But market interventions have taken on a different form — of forced non-transparency. During the sub-prime crisis, banks have been able to convince authorities that the securities they held, containing mortgage bonds, were being sold in a panic. So the prices weren't real, and weren't really "fair-value", so they should be allowed some freedom in valuing those assets. (If the value of assets banks hold should fall, they can violate capital requirements, which means they're in trouble if they can't raise equity fast.) From Europe to America, authorities have given banks leeway in mark-to-market rules — but even today after one might admit that markets are in better shape, the suspension or watering-down of mark-to-market continues. It is indeed acceptable to live in a dream, as long as you don't have to wake up.

Strangely, that intervention rarely happens when prices go out of hand on the upside. Indeed, it can be career-threatening, or just bad karma. In 1996, Alan Greenspan, chairman of the U.S. Fed, stated that stocks were seeing "irrational exuberance" — but prices continued to go up, peaking nearly 70% higher in 2000. When housing all over the world went to unheard-of prices, the defense was that we have reached a new permanently high zone, not that the sudden price explosion was undesirable. Just before the Great depression of 1929, economist Irving Fischer said "Stock prices have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau" — note, not something like "these prices are unrealistic". Closer home, in October 2007, SEBI decided to request more information about certain investors who invested through P-Notes, and the markets hit the 10% lower circuit — no one likes it when they stop a good thing, no matter what shady deals were made to get there.

More recently, intervention has taken the form of replacement. Banks have horrendous assets on their books? Let the central bank buy them. In no other time would it be acceptable for a central bank to buy mortgages; if the RBI even so much as suggested it, all hell would break loose — but lo and behold, the US Fed has been buying them quite openly.

It has also been considered irresponsible if a country's central bank were to buy the country's bonds — a sure-recipe for inflation, if anyone in the non-developed world tried it, or so we have been told. But today, we'll throw those rules out the window. From the Fed to the European Central Bank, the daily routine is now to figure out how many more dollar or euro bonds they can buy, in the name of "stability". How could you blame the RBI for getting in on the act and buying our own long term rupee bonds?

The idea is to distort asset prices, because they are prices we like to look at. If bond prices are good — that is, yields are low — then people will believe that countries are solvent. But if you put lipstick on a pig, it's still a pig. Even with all that intervention, Greek bond yield spreads against the German bund crossed 10% - a sign of serious distress. Portugal will offer more bonds on Wednesday, but the markets are looking at 7% as a sign of "too much to bear". But everything is relative, really. In isolation, these yields look high, but Indian bond yields are already at 8%, and we are hardly an economy in distress. Even in India, where people argue on TV about whether the economy will sputter and choke to death if the RBI raises short term rates to say 7%, it was just 10 years ago when interest rates were 9% and higher.

Intervening in a market just because prices have gone to an extreme is sometimes required. Markets may be consumed by panic — where everyone sells because everyone else is selling and no one wants to be left holding the bag. The downside pressure could be eased by shutting down markets for a while, but it should also be understood that "extreme" usually does not violate long term boundaries. The US had not seen housing prices drop for 15 years or so before 2006, but price declines have been an inalienable part of US housing over the century, and regardless of interventions, that market will find its way down to longer term averages, and probably over-correct as well. In India, we've not seen a recession of any serious sort in the recent past; even a real estate shock may be unknown to the broker with 10 years in the business. So there will be calls for intervention when there is an "extreme" price move, but in reality, we need to recognize that we have been out of whack for way too long. Our markets are overvalued. Inflation is going out of control by all historical measures. Our interest rates aren't high enough. We have to be ready to take a serious jolt through either extreme interest rates or a big slowdown (or both!) before inflation can come back under control — but the easier choice will be to intervene on extremes, "calm" our markets and people, and kick the can down the road. After all, in the long term, we are all dead.

More Yahoo Columns:

Showing 2 comment(s)

,cheap nike nfl jerseysHeritage Christian’s Jazmine Harris and New Berlin Eisenhower’s Jenny Weiland have accepted scholarship offers to play in college.Harris, a 6-foot forward who led Heritage Christian to the Division 5 state title,nfl jerseys cheap, will play at Division I Northern Illinois for Kathi Bennett, In addition to earning all-state honors in Division 5 from the Wisconsin Basketball Coaches Association, she earned third team all-state recognition from the Associated Press.Harris displayed a nice shooting touch and averaged 12.3 points and 9.8 rebounds per game last season,2012 Nfl jersey for cheap. During the offseason, she played with WBA Prestige and improved as a scoring threat from the wing and post,nike nfl jerseys 2012.“She knew her chances of playing collegiately would improve immensely if she was a more versatile player, so she put the time in to develop her game," Prestige director Moya Baylis said,, another Prestige player, helped New Berlin Eisenhower reach the Division 2 state final. The 5-11 forward committed to Division IIWinona State. She averaged 10.8 points per game and was a first-team all-Woodland Black pick last season. "She’s what we call a tweener. She plays (power forward and center) for us,Nike Green Bay Packers Jerseys, but she’s a 3 (small forward) in college," Eisenhower coach Gary Schmidt said. "She’s a tough matchup because she’s got size and quickness.&quot,Reebok Authentic Jerseys;

relate article:

,2752Through his critique,2237, Wang's paintings weave intricate narratives,24707, implicating the role on the artist as an active participant (both as subjugator and subservient) in economic and social policy. Wang treads a really delicate line between moral dictum and capitalist endorsement; the interpretation of his paintings alternates with all the subjectivity of context. Amalgamating,14078, confusing,18586, and blurring opposing ideological beliefs,12287, Wang's billboard sized canvases readily become unattainable national valour,6570, while simultaneously devaluing status symbol luxury with the proletariat cause. Many government funded research has been brushed under the carpet when they didn't turn the negative results intended. Research has shown everything,3678, from cannabis?failure to improve death rates (Sidney,20186, S et al. ?arijuana Use and Mortality?,20302, its deficiency of long lasting consequences (Eisen SE et al. oes Marijuana Use Have Residual Uncomfortable side effects on Self-Reported Health Measures,8398, Socio-Demographics or Standard of living??,24907, it can easily prevent cancer (multiple studies) knowning that it can have medicinal value (Joy,3349, JE,6326, Watson,2349, SH and Benson,20899, JA. arijuana and Medicine: Assessing the Science Base?. These these has been largely ignored from the government,23666, and caused the co-author John A. Benson to tell the modern York Times which the government ould rather it never happened.? You've probably heard about uggs discount. It's simply on everyone's wish list due to this season. This means that they can be selling continually. Many stores both on the internet and neighborhood are running out of UGGs stocks. Be it last year's style or the 2010 technology,2640, UGGs are getting had sell outs. For many UGG enthusiasts,21751, the sole other option is to consider discount UGGs in online auction marketplace sites. Your look directly speaks for your personality. Everything you select wearing will say regarding your taste and approach towards life. Plenty of contemporary females are familiar with this and bear it planned while you shop for closet items. From Oprah Winfrey include the different pairs few throughout his program,14389, the celebrities have encouraged these hunter wellingtons fixed and make the support for these boots or shoes. Shortly following this unique,23649, there is absolutely no denying that shoes sheepskin Australia's unique style became popular car land until it is a dominant fashion tattoo today. In case you are fashion conscious,15639, it is possible to be aware that 2010 UGG alignment are usually noted with some cutting edge additions. You've that may admit that while delivering the desirable qualities,11237, that include fit,21393, comfort,26790, durability and complete quite frequently,4033, the designers in this brand in any way stop turning with the most up-to-date fashion periodicals. here comes a fast list of some freshly released styles UGG overshoes sale charming gray. There are numerous basic styles for starters. First button is known as Bailey trio is anticipated to trend this coming year. button ingenious design and layout belonging to the shares accessible for decorative but useful is certainly developed. This design will be the improved version from the classic boots Sundance UGG Cardy together with Bailey also change button within the very same time. Then,25810, the style along with the axes on the knee high note with three buttons around the relief accessible to help very expressive versatility trend statement. Tall UGG bootsThe range Classic Tall boot provides relaxation and fashion,19435, even from your worst on the cold months of winter. With designs of realistic sheepskin,11518, feet continues dry and comfortable,14408, inspite of how cold the temperatures are wet. Other high boots is the lighthouse and Wrangell,7511, boots lined with sheepskin related to men with rUGGed rubber soles intended to provide excellent traction,8957, potentially in rain and wind generator. All Ugg boot are designed to give you a pleasant setting that passes by easily. Short UGG bootsShort Uggs are additionally available,10428, allowing people who do not require insurance at the high starting out take pleasure in the warmth and capability of UGG winter points in the protection. Button boots like Bailey and then the Ultra Short provide you with the warmth and privacy with the sheepskin filling in boots that only go to the bottom in the leg. With leather uppers along with rubber soles,24626, a lot of the boots offer exceptional the traction,7207, keeping the classical attractiveness of Ugg boot. Mini UGG BootsFor people would prefer to wear shoes,5391, UGG provides vintage Mini. These mini boots are created to only cover the camp and ankle,10267, like shoes. With all the backing involving large sheepskin,4070, due to the fact mini still give you the warmth and dryness that Uggs are recognized for,13074, and make a statement in the hip shoes. While the classic Mini cannot be the best choice meant for harsh weather,7649, they would definitely be a great lightweight option intended for cold days. For females who select comfort over fashion - but nonetheless wants to remain in style - Tamara Mellon has established a fix: the trio button UGG Boot footwear BaileyUGG Boots Australia is frequently very fashionable,12529, which is often a real advantage in purchasing comfortable boot. We're going to require sometime to think about Uggs more sturdy,1451, which may be put to use in casual dress,18082, throughout that the mountain hiking / climbing but still look fantastic,24659! ugg boot sale discount,25495, uggs sale,10912, ugg boot sale discount China can be a different world then what we should know and it also possesses many attractions which draw people through the far reaches from the globe. Thus translators have made important contribution within the centuries in dissemination of ideas and data to a larger audience,20647, in shaping of cultures as well as in an awareness of helped unite the entire world. Now sharp cuts to officer figures pushed by Britain's austerity measures,11058, sweeping reforms that threaten to inject politics into decision producing,9649, the fallout of England's riots and harsh realities of protecting the public from threats like suicide bombers leaves the country's fabled police in crisis.Capping the agony,20776, Cameron has turned for tips to ex-Los Angeles,14377, Nyc and Boston Police Chief William Bratton - dubbed "supercop" after his pioneering strategy sent crime rates tumbling in individuals U.S. cities."You are near a turning position,19572," mentioned Maurice Punch,18591, the article author of many books on British policing. "What transpired a week ago just accelerated that,22089, there is essential undertake a major review,11033, to contemplate a phase again as well as the public to question what type of policing they need."Officers and analysts acknowledge the debate is urgent,7244, with London's 2012 Olympic Video games looming. But,2973, with relations among Britain's public and its particular police under strain,12283, there remain deep divisions and uncertainty about whether or not Britain's cops are way too difficult or as well gentle.Police wound up chastened through the 2005 shooting dying connected with an innocent Brazilian electrician,14865, mistaken by police marksmen for just a suicide bomber,21276, and sharply criticized in excess of the dying of the bystander amid protests with a 2009 Band of twenty summit. Demonstrators who marched towards a hike in university tuition expenses,9911, and anti-monarchists who opposed April's royal wedding,4051, develop the two complained in latest months that officers have utilised abnormal power in derived from their protests.It meant that when disorder started in London on Aug. six - sparked by an to start with peaceful protest greater than a scarce deadly police shooting - the response appeared hesitant.Officers avoided confrontation like a demonstration within the Tottenham district of north London spiraled into prevalent lawlessness,13041, also it would have been a few days before police chiefs flooded the streets of Britain's capital with reinforcements."The massive problem is,9455, whenever you phase rear as a result,4041, how appropriate would be the previous paradigm?" mentioned Punch,23332, and a policing expert linked to the London School of Economics. Such as the Police Federation,26544, which represents about 125,7241,000 rank and file police,13527, he believes a Royal Commission - by far the most rigorous type of British govt inquiry - needs to plot an easy method ahead.Not like France and other European nations who have committed riot police,25397, Britain utilizes volunteer officers to abandon usual duties when condition arises. Countless police from across Britain sped to London to assist calm final week's condition - a tactic that will occur underneath strain as budgets are reduce.For Punch and other people,15077, one specific of the pressing issues is Britain's unusual usage of weapons,6116, still its most visible indicator of policing restraint.Inside Victorian times,10582, London police had an armory of 5,15122,000 swords,24373, though the blades ended up being stored blunted and officers warned they could be sacked when they drew the weapon.Of Britain's latest 144,14932,000 police only seven,26524,000 are authorized to transport a gun and very rarely rely on them - firing on just six occasions amongst April 2009 and March 2010 relating to the majority up-to-date accessible figures. In comparison,10805, just about all police in the United States possess a handgun,22994, with several authorized to utilize more powerful weapons. Having a wonderful fit around the calf helps to make the difference. If your boot is too tight,19722, you can get the calf muscle to bulge too much,3440, spoiling the cloths line and looking out below attractive,5399! Many high-street boots are designed to fit a regular size,4526, that is not good to your woman who doesn't fit this mythical profile. The most beneficial approach is usually to contact a manufacturer or supplier of boots that supply a wide range of calf fittings to find the right boot for ones leg shape. The length is usually important. If a knee high boot is simply too long it may push from the kneecap and grow uncomfortable in a short time. Again,20403, specialist suppliers is able to offer varying lengths to fit the 'real' woman's requirements. China has become a famous terminus for tourists and businessmen and they also visit China to find out,24482, amongst other things,2252, the Great Wall of China which is one of several Seven Wonders around the globe. Chinese language and writing courses are attending by many of the tourists and businessmen to converse and view the Far east. It is now possible to leaning Chinese at no cost throughout the China lessons offered on the internet.


Post new comment

Leave a comment, suggestion or ask a question!