Network18 Footnotes: Compensation, No Subsidiary Results, Investments

Sometimes, looking at pure results isn’t enough; what’s in the actual footnotes throws up interesting points. Take Network18’s September 2010 results.

Auditors have made three notes to the results.

Manager Compensation

The auditors have stated:

The Statutory Auditors have qualified their report on standalone accounts in respect of (i) remuneration paid to the Managing Director, being in excess of the limits prescribed in Schedule XIII of the Companies Act, 1956, … Management Response: (i) The Company has filed an application with the Central Government in December 2009 for seeking necessary approval and the same is awaited. …

Raghav Bahl gets a salary of 1.09 cr. according to the last annual report. That isn’t really much, but obviously too much for a loss making company. Yet, it’s strange that it’s nearly a year since permission was requested and it hasn’t been granted.

In 2009, they actually conducted a postal ballot for the “waiver of recover of excess remuneration paid to Mr. Raghav Bahl”. And it went through.

TIFC and FIML results not disclosed

The statement is:

The Statutory Auditors have qualified their report on consolidated accounts in respect of non consolidation of financials of The Indian Film Company Limited (TIFC) and Film Investment Managers (Mauritius) Limited (FIML). Management Response: The Management is of the view that since investments in TIFC and FIML are in the process of being disposed (see note 8(a) above) such consolidation is not required.

(Note 8 (a) is simply a statement that they are disposing of these assets)

Strange that they are allowed to do this – how can they not consolidate results, EVEN if there is a sale waiting to happen? The auditors have (naturally) complained about this – it doesn’t make any sense.

And on October 4, 2010, they announce the sale of TIFC – uhem – to Roptonal Limited, which is a subsidiary of Viacom 18, which in turn is a 50-50 joint venture between IBN18 and Viacom. IBN18 is also a subsidiary of Network18. What a mess.

More importantly, Viacom18 will continue to be 50% owned by Network18, even after the new restructuring, or so it seems. So they can run, but not hide – eventually all of it will have to be accounted for.

Network18 will make a profit on the trade – since they bought at around 40p per share  and are selling at 115p. Yet, is it a profit if you sell to yourself? (The market price was around 37.5p) According to the PR, the cash inflow into Network18 is 350 cr. from the sale.

No losses shown for fall in prices of owned shares

Network18 owns shares in public entities, like IBN18 and TV18, and in a slew of unlisted companies. These shares seem to have lost a lot of value, but Network18 is unwilling to take the loss. Their stance:

The Statutory Auditors have qualified their report on standalone accounts in respect of … (ii) non provision of other than temporary dimunition in the value of long term investments/advances of 39,562.51 lakhs. Management Response: ..(ii) No provision is necessary keeping in view the long term involvement of the company with the investee companies and in view of the proposed reorganization referred to in 3 above.

The auditors seem to think the total amount is higher. In their assessment, they mention that the “goodwill” amount of 1255 crores has a part that is invested in other group companies, whose net worth is eroded, but the goodwill amount has not been taken down. Investments of 733 crores are in downline joint ventures whose net worth has been “substantially eroded”, but there is no impairment taken. We don’t know how much the actual impairment will eventually be, of course but the amounts are fairly large.

(Personally, I think they might eventually stuff all the loss into one quarter, and hope that we won’t notice).

While this sounds shady, it’s par for the course in India where many companies simply refuse to bother about strange things like accounting standards. But since the investor community seems to consist of people who don’t give a rat’s ass, their share continues to maintain its price. But eventually, the cookie will crumble.

Network18 results

The improvement this quarter seems to be on the back of ignoring financial accounting requirements to an extent. But how much, we’ll never know.

Share price:

Network18 share price

There’s a lower support of 130 but as you can see, the volumes have dried up and the stock’s looking to go below. It has fallen substantially from the highs of 500+ in Jan 2007. For those investors, it has not been a fun ride. TV18 is quoting at 71, lower than the rights issue last year, and IBN18 at 89, again lower than the rights issue earlier this year. It’s a sad story for investors, honestly. The footnotes make it worse.

Showing 3 comment(s)

nfl jerseys 2012 matters exercised fine
range $59. 99-$69. 99, Houston Texans jerseys are made by means of two-fold number telephone number for frontal and additionally lower back area of a. nfl jerseys 2012 ll the jerseys, wide range $59. 99-$69. 99, Indiana Colts will give a fabulous recognise about two-fold deprive into your shoulder mu. nfl jerseys 2012 scles mostly in white and additionally along with white color choice, wide range $59.. 99-$69. 99, Jacksonville Jaguars are going to have wlq-zll121107 one-time deprive on the activate for the jerseys attainable right from $59. 99-$69. 9. Indianapolis Colts Jerseys 9, Kansas locale chiefs include pinkish, along with white, start from $59. 99-$69. 99, Minnesota Dolphins include along with. Indianapolis Colts Jerseys white and additionall.y coastal alternative, Mn Viking start from $59. 99-$69. 99 for along with white window treatments as well color choice, Minnesola Cutting edge The unit. New nfl jerseys ed kingdom Pictures, Saints, Texas Aircraft, Oakland Raiders, Philadelphia Eagles, Pittsburgh Steeler, North park Chargers, San fran 49. New nfl jerseys ers, Seattle Seahawks, E LOUIS Rama, Tampa Clean Buccaneers, Tn Titans, Wa Redskin all of t.he include $59. 99 -$69. 9

Relating to Televesion's Boyfriend Caves, ex-NFL music artist Tony adamowicz Siragusa implements palatial playp. New York Giants Jerseys ens just for hubbies moved to home decorating sidelines.

All the The big players troubled glory for go on Feb Tremendously R. New York Giants Jerseys n prepared John Tulloch and .additionally an individual's contacts deliriously cheerful. However, the key so next dawn, appalled inside the assert for the living room space with th. nfl jerseys 2012 eir Western side Orange colored place, Tulloch fianc, Stacy Settembrino, plonked the dog in a impairment.

previously had soup drop re. lating to the computer, tells Stacy, 25, a fabulous Lyndhurst knowledge consultant.. ow I had a fabulous discoloration relating to the brown area rug which usually collected set up. Document was first want, Document cannot really exe. nfl cheap jerseys cute this now! br >
Stacy Settembrino becomes Stacy Tulloch, for that reason matters exercised fine on her and additionally John, a . nfl cheap jerseys fabulous 27-year-old debt analyzer. Anticipate, in one week or possibly couple of as so.on as Tremendously Run, Stacy was first looking for horticultural helpful hints over the internet for the LEARNING TO MAKE (Do The software Yourself) lin.e funnel the moment this girl ran across a really perfect formula.

Boyfriend Caves, a real possibility express when a party about hammer-and-saw implements daydream hangouts just for harried partners, was first soliciting seekers for Nj. By means of Stacy confidence, John quizzed all the expres.s to show an individual's incomplete cellar perfectly into a club style just for an individual's most popular party, all the Mets, for that reason an individual's contacts could possibly have a point to make sure you hoot and additionally holler and additionally allow soup drop crash just where could possibly.

Interested through amazing capability for the living-room disagreement, all the manufacturing businesses created a fabulous show try just for John and additionally Stacy. These were targeted right from within 3, 000 seekers that should be one in every of 12 subject areas for those express subsequently winter. (New assaults tell you 03. )

At the same time Va Woolf notoriously suggested if you have a lover requires a room or space about her very own to make sure you engage in free th.

relate article:

The Christian Louboutin Outlet take the manner of Red bottom shoes,that is classic,personality,distinguished,charming and graceful.Own one pair of Christian Louboutin Pumps Outlet are every woman's sweet dream. High heels make Cheap Coach Purses you sexy and elegance.Cixin with high-grade rabbit hair refined but become, all Christian Louboutin Boots Outlet show the beauties of elegance and noble, the ornament of shiny strawberry drill buckle. Coach Outlet Onlineprofessional design makes your foot more comfortable. Even more tantalizing,this pattern make your legs look as long as you can, Christian Louboutin Platforms Outlet will make you looked more factory outletEncase your feet in the truly stunning Romaine 120. One of our personal favorites, this classic Christian Louboutin Sandals Outlet is certain to Discount Coach Handbags give you the height and poise that every Christian Louboutin girl desires.

people are pursuing for Louis vuitton handbags cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is ferragamo shoes or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking Coach Outlet. When these are ferragamo belts , the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking coach handbags outlet are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion accessories for men and women long time ago.Coach Outlet Online If you have not yet tried Coach Purses Outlet, it's time to own one and feel the difference it can make to your personality. These are just brilliant and fabulous salvatore ferragamo shoes. They are most iconic and can provide you with a new feeling and enhance confidence. The quality of louis vuitton outlet online is just superior to what you have dreamt of. Today owning a new and trendy looking louis vuitton handbags saleare not only meant for the wealthy people.

Post new comment

Leave a comment, suggestion or ask a question!